SCOTT STREED SCOTT STREED

Can Mediation Work if We Don’t Get Along? Common Myths Explained

One of the most common questions people ask about mediation is simple—and completely understandable:

“Can mediation really work if we don’t get along?”

Many people assume mediation only works for couples or families who are already cooperative and amicable. In reality, mediation is often most effective in situations where communication has broken down.

Below, we address some of the most common myths about mediation and explain why conflict alone does not mean mediation will fail.

Myth #1: Mediation Only Works If Everyone Is Friendly

This is one of the biggest misconceptions about mediation.

Mediation is not about friendship or agreement—it is about structure. A trained mediator manages the conversation, keeps discussions productive, and prevents them from spiraling into personal attacks.

In fact, mediation is frequently used in:

  • High-conflict divorces

  • Parenting disputes

  • Probate disagreements among family members

  • Estate-related conflicts involving long-standing resentment

You do not need to like the other person for mediation to work. You only need a willingness to participate in the process.

Myth #2: If We’re Angry, Mediation Will Just Make Things Worse

Strong emotions are common in legal disputes. Mediation is designed with that reality in mind.

Unlike court proceedings—which often intensify conflict—mediation provides:

  • Clear rules for communication

  • A neutral third party to guide discussion

  • A setting focused on solutions rather than blame

Research consistently shows that mediation reduces conflict over time. Studies across family law and civil disputes show that approximately 70–85% of mediated cases reach settlement, even when the parties begin in disagreement.

Myth #3: The More Conflict There Is, the Less Likely Mediation Will Succeed

Actually, the opposite is often true.

When conflict is high, litigation tends to:

  • Increase legal fees

  • Prolong resolution timelines

  • Reduce control over outcomes

  • Damage long-term relationships

Mediation allows parties to address the root of disputes instead of battling over positions. Because parties retain control over decisions, they are often more willing to compromise than they would be in court.

Myth #4: Mediation Means Giving In or Losing Leverage

Some people worry that mediation requires them to “give up” important rights or accept an unfair outcome.

Mediation is voluntary. No agreement is final unless all parties consent. Participants may:

  • End mediation at any time

  • Consult with attorneys during the process

  • Decline proposals that do not protect their interests

In Washington State, mediated agreements can still be reviewed and formalized through the court, ensuring legal enforceability without full litigation.

Myth #5: Court Is Better When People Can’t Communicate

Court proceedings are adversarial by design. While litigation is necessary in some cases, it often amplifies conflict—especially when ongoing relationships are involved, such as co-parenting or family matters.

Mediation focuses on:

  • Practical problem-solving

  • Future-focused solutions

  • Reducing emotional and financial strain

National data consistently shows that mediated cases resolve faster and at significantly lower cost than litigated cases, with parties reporting higher satisfaction with outcomes.

When Mediation May Not Be Appropriate

While mediation works in many high-conflict situations, it is not suitable for every case. Situations involving coercion, safety concerns, or severe power imbalances may require alternative legal approaches.

A professional consultation can help determine whether mediation is appropriate for your circumstances.

The Bottom Line

Mediation does not require agreement, friendliness, or perfect communication. It requires structure, guidance, and a willingness to engage.

For many people who “don’t get along,” mediation offers a way forward that avoids prolonged conflict, excessive legal fees, and court-imposed decisions.

If you are unsure whether mediation can work in your situation, understanding your options is often the first step toward resolution.

Read More